Effects of Cold Temperatures on Pierce’s disease

We are investigating the response of Pierce’s diseased grapevines in the field and laboratory-greenhouse to cold – especially freezing – temperatures. The geographical distribution of PD, its therapy by freezing treatments, and the failures of most late season infections to survive the following winter all suggest that cold temperatures play a key role it the spread of PD in temperate climates, but more information is needed to determine the underlying cause of freezing mortality of the causal bacterium, Xylella fastidiosa. In field studies, we used infective insect vectors to inoculate X. fastidiosa into 12 vines each month at University viticultural plots in Oakville and Davis from April through August, 1997. We recorded symptoms and attempted to culture X. fastidiosa from inoculated vines at both sites in the fall of 1997 to determine infection rates. April and August inoculations at Oakville were lower than planned. We will record symptoms and diagnose inoculated vines for infection with X. fastidiosa in the fall of 1998 to reconfirm the recovery of most late season infections of X. fastidiosa that have been previously reported (in 1979) by observing symptoms. During January and February, we took cuttings from inoculated canes and rooted them in the greenhouse to assess the rate of spread of X. fastidiosa from the point of insect infection, based on the date of inoculation. We inoculated an additional set of Ruby cabernet vines in the Central Valley (Kearney Agricultural Station) and Cabernet Sauvignon vines at UC Davis in April, with additional inoculations planned for June and July, 1998. Some vines were inoculated with infective insect vectors and other vines with needle inoculations of cultured X. fastidiosa. These vines will be assessed in fall, 1998 and again in the fall of 1999 for continued survival of X. fastidiosa. We prepared pot-grown grapevines with Pierce’s disease, allowed them to become dormant outdoors, and tested the effects of various laboratory freezing treatments on the survival of X. fastidiosa. We completed freezing treatments over a range of temperatures in March, 1998. Preliminarily, we have not detected bacterial growth in about 70%of the plants, but we will assess the plants again in July. In addition, we are recording the effects of temperature on the survival or cultured cells of X. fastidiosa in various solutions to compare to mortality rates in dormant grapevines.

Effects on Vertebrates of Riparian Woodland Management for Control of Pierce’s

This study was initiated in cooperation with Professors Purcell and McBride to evaluate the effects on a variety of vertebrates of the removal of vegetation as well as planting of non-disease reservoir plants in riparian zones. Studies were initiated in 1997 with the establishment of eight plots, three on Conn Creek (open, managed, and not managed), and three on the Napa River (Ecological Reserve, managed, and not managed) in Napa County, and two (managed and not managed) on Maacama Creek in Sonoma County. Five sampling procedures are used per plot as follows: a.) Two “Trailmaster” bait stations once per month for 7 days, b.) 15 Sherman live traps for small mammals one night per month, c.) Three point census plots for birds once per week during the breeding season (approx. March 1 to June 15), d.) Eight nesting boxes for birds checked weekly during the breeding season and e.) Six 4-square foot reptile boards checked twice per month. Data are still too preliminary to analyze but there are some interesting trends. The bait stations showed the most common mammal to be the opossum. Larger mammal activity was highest in the Ecological Reserve and very low in the open grassy area. There was little difference between the managed and unmanaged areas. The most common mammal in the live traps was the deer mouse, Peromyscus spp. Activity was highest in the cleared area and lowest in the Reserve plot, with little difference between the managed and unmanaged areas. Over 60 species of birds were identified on the study plots during the breeding census and an extensive analysis of these results will be necessary before conclusions can be made. Six species of birds used the nest boxes and the highest occupancy rate was in the unmanaged area on the Napa River. The Reserve area had the lowest occupancy rate. Tree swallows were the only birds using boxes in the open area. The reptile boards were used by four species of lizards, two species of snakes, the Pacific tree frog, western toad, and a salamander. The most common organism was the western fence lizard. The highest use was in one of the managed areas on Conn Creek. The results to date are encouraging and with more data we should be able to say if management of riparian zones has an impact on a variety of vertebrates.

Examining Rootstocks and Vitis Species for Non-host Resistance to Pierce’s Disease

Major Objectives:

  1. To screen the following commonly used rootstocks for the ability to be symptomless carriers of, or non-hosts to, Pierce’s Disease Bacteria (PDB): St. George, 5C, 5BB, 161-49, 3309C, 101-14, Schwarzmann, 44-53 Mgt, 11 OR, 1103P, Ramsey, Freedom, Harmony, 039-16.
  2. To screen selections from rupestris X rotundifolia seedling populations for resistance/non-host status to PDB.
  3. To screen 4 accessions of each of a range southern Vitis species for susceptibility to PD; the ability to act as non-disease expressing carriers of PDB; and the ability to be non-hosts to PDB.
  4. To test the possibilities of grafting vinifera scions onto an infected stock/trunk combination, and grafting to non-hosts identified above under greenhouse and Davis field conditions, in preparation for future field studies.

Summary:

We have prepared plant materials for PD screening, developed the inoculation system, have optimized the PD – PCR detection system, and have seedlings from a cross of Chardonnay X (rupestris X rotundifolia). These plant materials will be inoculated with PD during summer 1998 and results should be ready near the end of 1998.

Management of Riparian Woodlands for Control of Pierce’s Disease in Coastal

The third year of this continuing project evaluated reducing Pierce’s disease (PD) of grapevines while restoring stream bank woodlands in north coastal California. By replacing wild grape, blackberry, and other plants used by BGSS for breeding with plants that are not favored by the BGSS for reproduction or feeding, the numbers of blue-green sharpshooters (BGSS) that we detected in yellow sticky traps were again reduced to significantly lower levels compared to undisturbed controls. Our tests of buffer strip plantings of redwood and Douglas fir between vineyards and riparian woodlands as a barrier to reduce the influx of BGSS into vineyards during spring have thus far been disappointing because of the long times required to generate buffer plants of a suitable size. Our second goal is to reduce the percentage of BGSS that are infective with the Pierce’s disease bacterium (Xylella fastidiosa) by replacing plants that support the multiplication, within-plant movements, and year-round survival of X. fastidiosa with plants that do not. Since June, 1997 we continued to record significantly decreased trap catches of BGSS in the removal and replanting treatments. Overall sticky trap catches of BGSS were reduced over 99%in the treatment in which vegetation was removed and replanted at our first site. At our second site (Napa River), where vegetation was first removed beginning in the growing season of 1996, we found that BGSS counts were reduced by over 70%, but most of the catches in the treated site were at one trap location, located near hillside vegetation that connected to the riparian zone. We established pretreatment (baseline) records of BGSS activity at a third site on Maacamas Creek in Sonoma County, where we began vegetation removal in late 1997, continued through the spring of 1998. Spring catches of BGSS in all sites were sharply lower than in previous years, probably because of cooler temperatures and rain. Effects of reduced numbers of BGSS on the spread of Pierce’s disease to adjacent vineyards will have to await the establishment of new vineyards being planted along some of the experimental areas.

Development and Evaluation of a Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) Assay for Detecting Xylella Fastidiosa in Plants

This was the second and final year of a project whose goal was to develop and evaluate a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay to detect Xylella fastidiosa (X.f), the bacterium which causes Pierce’s disease (PD) of grapevines. PCR results obtained in 1996/97 using chronically infected PD-grapevines located in the Napa Valley yielded results that were similar to those obtained in 1995-6. PCR and direct culture methods detected X.f. in woody cane samples collected during fall, winter and spring months during 1996-97. PCR consistently provided more sensitive detection of X.f compared to direct culture or ELISA, results which suggest that PCR will be a valuable research tool for screening grape germplasm accession for resistance to X.f Surprisingly, as in 1996, we did not detect the bacterium using PCR or culture until May, 1997 in leaves or stems of newly developed canes. Detection of the bacterium in the oldest leaves and shoots which developed from chronically infected spurs rose from 8%of the samples being positive on May 9 to 42%positive on June 9 and 75%positive on July 9, 1997. We will continue sampling these vines again in August and in the fall to complete this time course study. However, these results indicate that under Napa Valley conditions, X.f. multiplies to significant populations only after mid to late June. These results indicate that insect vectors are probably unlikely to acquire the bacterium from PD-infected grapevines until late June, which is consistent with the lack of evidence for vine to vine transmission of X.f. by sharpshooter vectors. In a previous study, we found that the X.f. bacterium was unlikely to survive the following winter in vines that were newly infected after May-June. The pattern of negative PCR reactions interspersed over the season with positive reactions from grapevines that were known to have Pierce’s disease indicates that the bacterium is irregularly distributed within infected grapevines. Because PCR normally uses only a very small (less than 0.1 gram) piece of tissue, we believe that some of our pathogen detection “misses” were the result of testing a small sample that did not happen to contain detectable numbers of X.f. In order to increase the size of the sample from a particular vine, we are now evaluating a technique called immunocapture PCR. This technique uses PD-specific antibodies to capture and immobilize X.f. bacteria on small beads that can be recovered with a magnet. The beads are then tested for the presence of bound X.f. using PCR. In this manner we can test several samples collected from various positions on the vine to increase the likelihood of detecting X.f. in the vine. Initial results using immunocapture PCR have been encouraging. We will continue this work and compare the relative sensitivities and reliability of direct versus immunocapture PCR.

Management of Riparian Woodlands for Control of Pierce’s Disease in Coastal California

This continuing project seeks to evaluate a new way to reduce Pierce’s disease (PD) of grapevines by managing stream bank woodlands in north coastal California to reduce populations of the blue-green sharpshooter (BGSS) and their level of infectivity with the bacterium, Xylella fastidiosa. By replacing wild grape, blackberry, and other plants used by BGSS for breeding with plants that are not favored by the BGSS for reproduction or feeding, the numbers of BGSS that we detected in yellow sticky traps were again reduced to very low levels compared to undisturbed controls. Fir trees in the buffer remained too small to have any expected effects on BGSS movements. Winter flooding and a dry spring prevented planting along the Napa River site. Seed for replants was collected and sown and seedlings for bare-root transplants are being grown in a commercial nursery for transplanting in fall, 1997 and winter, 1998. We received provisional approval from the California Dept. of Fish and Game to conduct riparian woodland management experiments at a new site in Sonoma County along Maacama Creek. Data on the infectivity of BGSS with Xylellafastidiosa showed that in one site (Conn Creek) infectivity was about 50%, compared to a range of about 5-15% the previous year and in the two other sites this year. This high level of infectivity at one location may simply be within the range of annual fluctuations in vector infectivity.

Pierce’s Disease Epidemiology and Management

This is the final year of a continuing project on the fate of the Pierce’s disease (PD) bacterium (Xylella fastidiosa) in various plant species. The selected plants are preferred by the principal insect vector of PD in coastal California, the blue-green sharpshooter (BGSS) or are common perennials in riparian vegetation. We inoculated plants in the lab with X. fastidiosa using infective BGSSs and inoculated plants in the field mechanically with cultured bacteria. After keeping the plants in a greenhouse or waiting 2-4 months for mechanically inoculated plants in the field to develop infections, we attempted to isolate the bacterium from the plants. We previously were not able to recover by culture X. fastidiosa from arroyo willow, red willow, sandbar willow, or yellow willow that had been inoculated by either method, but polymerase chain reaction assays indicated the presence of X. fastidiosa in willows in the field. After inoculating red or yellow willows with X. fastidiosa using BGSS, we recovered the bacterium in culture after less than 1 week (8 of 15 positive) and after 3 weeks (8 of 13 positive) but made only one recovery in 16 attempts after 12 weeks. We concluded that the bacterium undergoes a short period of growth in willow, but does not survive well beyond 2-3 months. This would explain previous reports that willow is a host of the bacterium, and might have caused the positive PCR results in willows from which we did not culture X. fastidiosa. To examine the effects of overwintering, we are maintaining greenhouse-infected plants outdoors at Oakville during the winter of 1996-97. These will be returned to the greenhouse in March, 1997 to hold for retesting (culture) later this spring. We have further refined and expanded our analysis of strains of X. fastidiosa. Pierce’s disease strains from Georgia and Florida are closely related to California strains, especially north coastal California strains. Strains from peach (phony disease), oak leaf scorch, and oleander leaf scorch are all quite distinct from grape and almond strains. Two of the almond strains overlapped slightly with grape strains.

Development and Evaluation of a Polymerase Chain

The primary objective of this research project was to develop and evaluate a more sensitive diagnostic assay for detecting Xylella fastidiosa (X.f), the bacterium that causes Pierce’s Disease (PD) of grapevines. The development of more sensitive diagnostic assays would greatly facilitate the identification of alternate plant reservoirs of PD and grape germplasm that is more resistant or tolerant of X.f. In 1995 we evaluated the utility of a new and very sensitive diagnostic test, called the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), for detecting X.f. in grapevines and other woody plants. PCR uses a special thermostable enzyme called Taq polymerase to amplify a specific fragment of X.f. DNA. The presence of the amplified DNA indicates that the sample was infected with the X.f. bacterium. We began our evaluation by testing the specificity and sensitivity of two different sets of PCR primers which direct the Taq enzyme to amplify the X.f DNA. Results showed that both sets of PCR primers, which amplify different fragments of X.f DNA, worked equally well in detecting X.f. in grapevines. PCR detected the X.f bacterium in dormant canes in March, however the percentage of positive detections was low. The frequency of positive detections increased in diseased canes as the season progressed and the ability to consistently detect X.f. by PCR, ELISA and cultural methods directly correlated with the development of leaf symptoms. PCR consistently provided the most sensitive detection of X.f in diseased grapevines, however a low percentage of false-positive test results occasionally occurred when testing cane scrapings. PCR also detected X.f. in other woody plants, such as red willow, maple, elderberry and wild grape, woody plants that can be difficult to analyze by ELISA. The most surprising, and potentially significant, result of testing diseased grapevines over the growing season was that no X.f bacteria were detected in emerging green shoots until the middle of June. This result indicates that Xf colonizes growing tissues quite slowly and that infected grapevines are probably not a significant reservoir of the pathogen until late July or August. This observation also suggests, but doesn’t prove, that dormant buds on diseased vines probably contain few viable bacteria and, theoretically, the disease should be difficult to transmit from dormant buds collected in late winter. Experiments are now in progress to verify this hypothesis. It was also determined, using a DNA fingerprinting technique, that X.f. strains collected from diseased grapevines located throughout California were genetically quite similar to eachother and to wild grape infected with X.f. More importantly, all of these geographically diverse strains were consistently detected by both sets of PCR primers. We believe that PCR could provide more reliable pathogen detection if methods were developed to sample larger portions of the vine, without having to do multiple PCR tests on the same vine. We are now evaluating the usefulness of a technique called immunocapture PCR, which uses X.f. -specific antibodies to trap X.f. bacteria, to test large-size samples. The relative sensitivity and reliability of immunocapture PCR, standard PCR, ELISA and cultural methods will be evaluated during 1996.

Management of Riparian Woodlands for Control of Pierce’s Disease

This is a continuing project to develop new methods of managing Pierce’s disease (PD) of grapevines by managing the plant habitats of the principal insect vector of PD, the blue-green sharpshooter (BGSS). Populations of BGSS would be reduced by replacing plants such as wild grape, blackberry, and others with plants that are not favored by the BGSS for reproduction or feeding. We are also testing buffer strip plantings of redwood and Douglas fir between vineyards and riparian woodlands as a barrier to reduce the influx of BGSS into vineyards during spring. The second goal is to reduce the percentage of BGSSs that are infective with the Pierce’s disease bacterium {Xylella fastidiosa) by replacing plants that support the multiplication, within-plant movements, and year-round survival of A”. Fastidiosa with plants that do not. Managing riparian woodlands to reduce the threat of PD also must meet requirements to maintain good habitats for fish and wildlife, prevent water contamination, and not degrade other public uses or values of this ecosystem. During 1995-96 we monitored populations of BGSS before and after the management treatments. We also estimated that about 6%of BGSS in the study site were infected with Z Fastidiosa in September, 1995. Sticky trap catches of BGSS along both sides of the study site along Conn Creek, Napa County, verified that BGSS was common along the entire study site. Trap catches in vineyards were much lower than in adjacent riparian vegetation (10%or less of riparian catches). During the fall, selected plants were removed from treatment plots by cooperating growers using California Conservation Corps work crews. Replantings and buffer strip plantings were made during February-March. Additional plantings to replace trees that died will be made after September, 1996, depending on rainfall. As expected, trap catches of BGSS were drastically reduced in plots where riparian vegetation was removed. Two additional experimental sites should be added in 1996. Approval from California Dept. Of Fish and Game for these experiments was given for a Napa River site. Permission will be sought to establish a Sonoma County site on Maacama Creek if BGSS activity proves to be sufficient based on our sampling of BGSS populations. Future replications of this experiment on other sites will give more realistic short term estimates of the effectiveness of the vegetation management approach because not as many large trees will be removed. A mix of University and AVF funding is planned to support this complex, multi-year project. This year funding (>$20,000/year) for 2 or 3 years shared funding has been awarded through a competitive grant from the California Department of Pesticide Regulation.

Pierce’s Disease Epidemiology and Management

This continuing project studied what happens to the Pierce’s disease (PD) bacterium {Xylella fastidiosa) in various plant species. We selected plants that are preferred by the principal insect vector of PD in coastal California, the blue-green sharpshooter (BGSS). We used infective BGSSs to inoculate plants in the lab with X. Fastidiosa. After keeping the plants in a greenhouse or waiting for mechanically inoculated plants in the field to develop infections, we attempted to isolate the bacterium from the plants. We recovered X. Fastidiosa for both types of inoculation from buckeye, valley oak, elderberry, and big leaf maple. We recovered bacteria from ash, coast live oak and bay laurel from BGSS-inoculated plants in the greenhouse but not from field-inoculated plants. We did not recover bacteria from alder, black walnut, arroyo willow, red willow, or sandbar willow that had been inoculated by either method or from cottonwood that had been mechanically inoculated. We recovered X. fastidiosa from mechanically-inoculated wild plum, which was not tested using BGSS inoculation. We kept all greenhouse-infected plants outdoors at Oakville during winter, 1995-96 and returned them to the greenhouse to hold for retesting (culture) later this summer. Many normally deciduous species (oaks, for example) kept their leaves throughout the very mild winter. We have reisolated X. fastidiosa from overwintered California blackberry. An analysis of DNA differences among 29 strains from grape or almond grouped strains into 3 clusters: north coast strains (no almond tested), most almond strains (Central Valley), and southern and central California strains (almond and grape).